The Pup Tent Party?

Elizabeth Warren and Nancy Pelosi, both of whom actually belong to the Democratic Party, said what shouldn’t have needed to be said: DNC Chairman Tom Perez was wrong when he said the national party would not support any candidate who did not support reproductive rights. Here’s part of what Perez said:

Every Democrat, like every American, should support a woman’s right to make her own choices about her body and her health. That is not negotiable and should not change city by city or state by state.

He is right. Everyone should support reproductive rights for women and those rights should not change depending on where you happen to live. But he is wrong to ignore the reality of American politics. Pro-choice Democrats can’t get elected in some places.

Both Warren and Pelosi are, in Warren’s words, “strongly pro-choice.” Pelosi said:

I have served many years in Congress with members who have not shared my very positive — my family would say aggressive — position on promoting a woman’s right to choose.

Image result for warren and pelosiBut both of these powerful Democrats recognize, as do most party leaders, that the issue of abortion is one that plays differently in Louisiana than it does in Massachusetts or California. We should remember that when Democrats held a majority in the House in 2009, it was because more than three dozen anti-choicers called themselves Democrats.

Leading Democrats have more work to do in convincing an overwhelming majority of people that women should be able to control their own bodies, should be able to make their own choices about having children and how many they should have. Until then, we have to live with the fact that not everyone, including not everyone in the Democratic Party, agrees with the party’s platform on the issue. Warren put it well:

I recognize that not all of my colleagues agree with me. I’ll do everything I can to persuade them, but they are my colleagues, and that’s just how it is with the Democrats. But I got to say, it does not dampen my energy in this fight.

It’s the same way with issues like single-payer health insurance. Many Democrats don’t support the concept, either as a revolutionary change in our system or even as an incremental change, step by step until we get there. These Democrats need to be convinced otherwise, as far as I’m concerned. But if they are willing to fight for other issues that we Democrats have in common, then they should be welcome in our party to fight with us on those issues.

The two major political parties in our system are, by the nature of the case, full of all kinds of people with all kinds of views on all kinds of issues. There is no one issue that defines what a Democrat is, even if there does come a point where you can disagree with so many core principles of the party that you should just call yourself something else and get out of the tent.

Previous Post


  1. Duane. I am a registered Democrat — have been since 1975. I agree with you on most issues and I think that suffices to keep us in the same tent. There will never (I hope) be some Dem version of GOP party purity that sucks critical thinking and individuality and conscience out through the ears.
    I have never been a registered Socialist, but I like many of the tenets of democratic socialism.
    I believe we could learn more than a little from Sweden and Denmark and the way they do government. That said, I’m in the Democratic Party for the long haul. You and King and Jim and Anson can belittle me all you want: I’m an old man — I’m willing to put up with shit in order to listen to and participate in the conversation. I will tell you that I get weary of the corporate party line, well-held by this blog, but I also think we’re all trying to do the right thing.
    Maybe even Anson? Maybe.
    Here’s the thing: this party will not grow without the Sanders-Warren left-leaning wing coming enthusiastically on board. (I know you don’t like Sanders and Warren sharing a hyphen, but you’d best get over it: they do.)
    As long as the Corporate Democrats control what happens in the corporate media and continue slamming the Sanders camp, the young are gonna run for the cover — of nothing. Sanders will not bow the knee to a dysfunctional, big business party. He’ll still vote the right way. He’ll still champion the causes that will resonate with most Americans. And as long as Corporate Dems continue to slam him, the rest of the country will scratch their heads and ask WTF is wrong with these old line losers? Because losers is what the Democratic Party will continue to be — election after election. We don’t have the map — the gloriously gerrymandered map. We don’t have the Court. We don’t have enough big money to beat the really big money. We don’t have Putin. We will continue to naively believe the US is still a democracy.
    The only way to actually return to democracy is to kick the money and corporate influence out. All the way out. You may think that can’t happen, but if it doesn’t and if we don’t embrace the people trying to bring about that change, we’re screwed long and short term.
    Our tent can continue to be a patchwork affair — as long as we don’t get arrogant and lazy and exclusive. If there’s enough room in that tent for Elizabeth Warren, Al Franken, Mark Warner, Tim Kaine, Joe Donnelly and Dianne Feinstein — there should be enough room for me.

    Liked by 1 person

  1. This Post Isn’t For Everybody | The Erstwhile Conservative: A Blog of Repentance
%d bloggers like this: